The Midtown Collapse Scare
The city's largest office-to-residential conversion nearly fell from the inside out, and The City Reporter found that officials had known about the site's safety problems since spring 2025.

Two structural columns on the 21st floor of 235 East 42nd Street, the former Pfizer headquarters being converted to 1,600 apartments by developer MetroLoft, buckled Tuesday morning after workers reported bricks falling; the FDNY established a collapse zone, evacuated 400 children from a school in the immediate area, and shut down 42nd and 43rd streets between First and Third Avenues. [41] The buckled columns sit directly below a planned "horizontal bump-out" expansion widening floors 23 through 32, though Buildings Department officials say investigators have not determined whether the expansion played a role. [74] By Tuesday evening, engineers found no further movement in the damaged columns and authorized contractors to begin installing temporary shoring; some nearby residents were allowed home while others awaited clearance. [80]
“The box beams — the steel beams — had started to bend.”
“We want to confirm that the affected area is a small section of one of the two buildings on this site.”
- 7construction safety violations at 235 East 42nd in 2025, all classified "immediately hazardous"; certificates of correction accepted, no fines paid [103]
- $98.7 millionestimated project cost; MetroLoft also plans four new rooftop floors and a 19-level addition to an adjacent building [80]
- 400children evacuated from a nearby school [41]
- Spring 2025:DOB began receiving complaints about unsafe conditions at the job site, records obtained by The City Reporter show [41]
- Dec 2025:235 GC LLC cited for failing to notify DOB of a worker injury, a $10,000 penalty; second December violation for a worker falling six feet from an unlevel ladder [103]
- Today:Columns buckle on the 21st floor; evacuation; stabilization work begins by evening [41]

