Guides Prices checked October 5, 2026
Where to stay in New York: the neighborhoods, the real nightly cost, and the Airbnb rule
Pick the subway line before the hotel. Seven bases compared, the 14.75% in taxes the headline price leaves out, and the Airbnb law that rules out most whole apartments.
The short answer
First visit and a short stay: Midtown West, where twelve subway lines meet at Times Square and Port Authority. Want more room for the money: Long Island City, one stop from Grand Central on the 7. Budget about 14.75% in taxes plus $3.50 a night in fees on any room of $40 or more, so a $300 night costs about $348. A whole apartment for under 30 days is not legal under Local Law 18. Checked October 2026.
- Room taxes About 14.75% + $3.50/night
- $300 room, all in About $348
- Average room, 2025 $334 (NYC Tourism)
- Whole-apartment Airbnb Not legal under 30 days
- Resort fees Must be in the advertised price
Free. One email each morning. One-click unsubscribe. Never sold.
Choose by train line, not by landmark
New York is small enough that the train you sleep near matters more than the neighborhood's name. A hotel two blocks from a station with four lines puts most of the city within half an hour; a cheaper room a 15-minute walk from a single local line costs you that half hour twice a day. Our advice: decide what you will do most (shows, museums, the parade, the Marathon, a business district), find the lines that serve it, then search for rooms near those stations. The bullets beside each pick below are the lines at its main stations.
Seven bases, compared
Paid links. We earn a commission if you book through some links in this guide, at no extra cost to you. It never decides what we recommend.
-
Midtown West and Times Square
The most hotel rooms in the city, a walk to every Broadway theater, and the station complex at Times Square and Port Authority that reaches almost anywhere without a transfer. It is the easiest base for a first visit or a short stay, and the one to pick for the Thanksgiving parade or New Year's Eve.
-
Midtown East and Grand Central
Quieter at night than the West Side, with Grand Central for Metro-North and the 7 straight to Queens. A good base for a work trip, the Rockefeller tree and the Fifth Avenue windows.
-
Lower Manhattan and the Financial District
Fulton Street and the World Trade Center are two of the best-connected stations in the city, the PATH runs to New Jersey, and the Staten Island Ferry, the Statue of Liberty boats and the 9/11 Memorial are a walk away. The streets empty out after office hours, which suits some travelers well.
-
SoHo and the Lower East Side
Smaller hotels, the shopping streets, and the restaurants and bars of downtown. This is the base for a trip built around food and long walks.
-
Long Island City, Queens
The best value base we know of for a Midtown-heavy trip. Vernon Blvd-Jackson Av is one stop from Grand Central on the 7, Court Square has the E and M into Midtown, and the waterfront has the skyline view Manhattan hotels charge for.
-
Downtown Brooklyn and Williamsburg
Downtown Brooklyn has a dense cluster of newer hotels on top of a major transit hub, a walk from the Brooklyn Bridge and Brooklyn Heights. Williamsburg, one stop from Manhattan on the L, is the pick for nightlife and the waterfront.
-
Jamaica, Queens, for an early flight
Jamaica station has the AirTrain to JFK, the LIRR and the subway in one complex, so a hotel near it puts an early flight within one AirTrain ride. It is a working neighborhood, not a sightseeing base.
What a room costs once the taxes are added
The price on a search page is the room. New York adds an 8.875% sales tax (state, city and the 0.375% transportation district tax), a 5.875% city hotel occupancy tax, a city flat fee of $2 a night on rooms of $40 or more, and a state fee of $1.50 per unit per night. Together that is about 14.75% plus $3.50 a night (rates checked October 2026 on tax.ny.gov and nyc.gov).
| Line | Rate | On a $300 room |
|---|---|---|
| Room | Advertised price | $300.00 |
| Sales tax | 8.875% | $26.63 |
| City hotel occupancy tax | 5.875% | $17.63 |
| City flat fee | $2.00 a night (rooms $40 and up) | $2.00 |
| State unit fee | $1.50 a night | $1.50 |
| Total | About 14.75% + $3.50 | $347.76 |
Resort fees now have to be in the price. Since February 2026 a city rule from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection requires hotels to show the total price including mandatory fees, such as resort, destination or facility fees, wherever they advertise it. Taxes can still be added at checkout, which is why the table above matters. A law firm's reading of the rule says it reaches booking sites too (checked October 2026).
When rooms cost the most
NYC Tourism + Conventions reported an average room rate of $334 and occupancy of 84.2% for 2025. Summer 2026 ran far higher with the World Cup in town: CoStar put July's average at $351.18, up 24% on the year (checked October 2026). Our advice: the weeks of the United Nations General Assembly, Thanksgiving, mid-December and New Year's Eve fill first, so book those as early as you can with free cancellation, and look again closer to the date. January and February are the traditional low season.
The Airbnb rule
Under Local Law 18, a short-term rental in New York City of under 30 days must be registered with the Office of Special Enforcement, the host must live in the home during your stay, and there can be no more than two guests (children under 4 don't count). Platforms may not take payment for a listing that is not registered, and a legal listing shows its registration number. So a whole apartment for a week, with no host there, is almost never legal. The city counted more than 3,500 approved hosts in its fiscal 2026 report. Bills to loosen the rules for one- and two-family homes were in committee when we checked in October 2026.
The questions people actually ask
What is the best area to stay in New York for a first visit?
Midtown West, near Times Square and Port Authority. Twelve subway lines meet there and most of what a first visit includes is a walk or a single train away. If the price is too high, Long Island City in Queens is one stop from Grand Central on the 7.
How much are hotel taxes in New York City?
About 14.75% of the room rate (8.875% sales tax plus a 5.875% hotel occupancy tax) plus $3.50 a night in flat fees on rooms of $40 or more. A $300 room comes to about $348. Checked October 2026.
Is Airbnb legal in New York City?
Only in a narrow form. Under Local Law 18, a stay of under 30 days must be in a registered home where the host lives and is present, with no more than two guests. Renting a whole apartment for a short stay is not legal, and platforms may not process payment for unregistered listings.
Is it cheaper to stay in Brooklyn or Queens?
Often, for the same standard of room, and Long Island City and Downtown Brooklyn are both a short ride from Manhattan. Compare the total for your dates; it is not true every night, and a long walk to the station can cancel the saving.
Do New York hotels still charge resort fees?
They can charge mandatory fees, but since February 2026 a city rule requires them to be included in the advertised price. Taxes are still added at checkout. Checked October 2026.
When is the cheapest time to book a hotel in New York?
January and February are the traditional low season. The most expensive weeks are the UN General Assembly in September, Thanksgiving, mid-December and New Year's Eve.
The sources
Where the prices and rules above come from. Check them yourself:
- NY State Department of Taxation: hotel and motel occupancy (TB-ST-331) — Sales tax and the $1.50 unit fee
- NYC Department of Finance: hotel room occupancy tax — The city's flat fee tiers
- NYC Office of Special Enforcement: what is Local Law 18
- NYC DCWP: hotel consumer and worker protections — The all-in price rule
- NYC Tourism + Conventions annual report, March 2026 — 2025 room rate and occupancy
- Hotel Online: CoStar July 2026 U.S. hotel performance
The prices on this page change.
When one moves, this guide is corrected and the morning brief says so. Get the brief and you get the update the day it lands, with the rest of New York explained alongside.
Free. One email each morning. One-click unsubscribe. Never sold.